Navigating the world with my inter-racial, inter-cultural family
rac·ism
n. 1. The belief that race accounts for differences in human character or ability and that a particular race is superior to others.
ist adj. & n.The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition copyright ©2000 by Houghton Mifflin Company. Updated in 2003. Published by Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved.
So I find myself reflecting on my own growth as a human, participating in American Society. As a white (partly Jewish) woman I was raised in a primarily white/Latino Southern California community. It was not until I was in college that I was exposed to a broader African American culture, Asian culture and even Jewish culture.
So I remained open and enjoyed exploring new boundaries, new cultures, and new colors. At 18 I started traveling overseas and lived among foreign races and cultures for almost a decade. I wonder if along the way that I said, or even thought ignorant things about people of other races. Does that make me a racist? Now that I am married to a black man, does that make me a reformed racist? A nice racist? I don’t think so, but maybe you feel differently.
I do know however what it feels like to be on the receiving end of racist and ignorant comments. It doesn’t feel good. Is that the essence of racism? Is that what makes someone a racist? When someone says or does something that acknowledges race, or a racial stereotype, and it’s result makes someone feel discriminated against? Is it valid to say that racism exists when the minority says so. I think so. Or even when just one person says so. Because that’s what truth is all about. My version of reality is not always your version of reality.
Take the example in my post “Ignorance or Racism?”. My husband didn’t perceive the man’s comment as racist until he came home and blew my top about it. So now it’s racist, or it always was?
So when is someone who has made a racist comment not considered a racist? Is it possible for a racist person to loose their racist tendencies? Does that make someone a reformed racist? How and when do we know that a transformation has occured? Do we have a responsibility to say something when racist comments happen? Do we have a responsibility to forgive racists or racist comments? How will we know when things have changed? Can a racist really change?
I am a white woman, mother of two, married to a man from the Eastern Caribbean. I work to understand my whiteness everyday; and though I am a bit of a Pollyanna, I hope you find substance in my writing. I welcome your comments.
Gori Girl
January 10th, 2009 at 2:54 pm
I think you’re making this a bit more complicated than it has to be. There’s a difference between ignorance and racism. Do you currently believe that a particular race is either superior to or inferior to another race? Do currently practice discrimination and prejudice against people because of their race?
If not, then you’re not a racist. You may inadvertently think racist thoughts, or participate in racist institutions – it can be difficult (impossible?) to get away from that sort of thing. But that’s different from being a racist, in the same way that a person act like an ass in a particular situation, while not actually being an asshole, generally speaking. (Feel free to edit if the language is too strong.)
Elizabeth
January 10th, 2009 at 5:14 pm
Thanks for your comment. Did you read the other post racism or ignorance?? I agree 100% with what you are saying. Do you think that the guy from that post who made the racist comment toward my husband was a racist or acting like an ass?
Shirl
January 11th, 2009 at 6:02 pm
Gori Girl says it very well.
“Do you currently practice discrimination and prejudice against people because of their race”.
The man’s comments in your earlier post are both. His comments convey what he believes and feels inside.
I’ve been guilty throughout my life of making racists comments about other ethnic groups and races. I’m not proud of it but feel I’ve grown from it and moved past it. I think that if everyone is honest they have done the same at some point in their lives. Does that make us all racists? No. Perhaps that makes us all recovering racists
You asked if we have a responsibility to address racial comments. Yes. I guess in a way that’s why I decided to write my blog. I hope maybe just one person will wake up and see through “different eyes”. The more we sanitize and sweep racism under the rug, the more it festers and digs in it’s ugly roots.
I also think forgiveness is essential to moving on from any sin, racism included. Is it easy? Not for me, but I’m working on it.
Great post!
Arwyn
January 27th, 2009 at 11:40 pm
This is why I think it’s much more useful to focus on labeling actions rather than labeling persons. What the guy said was emphatically racist, whether it was ignorant or malicious. I think it’s divisive and useless to question whether one IS “a racist”, but absolutely necessary to question whether a deed or thought is racist or steeped in privilege.
I don’t think anyone, and certainly no one with white privilege in this culture, can escape ever thinking or saying something racist, and no matter how much we may want to we can never get rid of our privilege. If having ever even inadvertantly supported or perpetuated racism were all it took to “be racist”, all white people and probably all people of color (hegemony) would be racist, which is not a definition I find particularly useful. Once that word gets applied (especially if, as a commenter on the other thread said, it’s an all or nothing proposition), people shut down, and stop being open to learning and just get defensive.
What I would then say distinguishes a racist from an antiracist then, if we are to insist on focusing on that label, is our openness to being called on the racist act or belief, our willingness to see it, and our desire and work to change it.
Elizabeth
January 28th, 2009 at 6:57 am
Thanks Arwyn. Great comment! I really appreciate your wisdom here. Your perspective is exactly what I needed to hear to pull myself out of this black and white/yin and yang view of the world…